9-4b2a1f Two-way debate benefits from criticism

Related:

• 4-1a4b3 If you write down ideas, you can have a conversation with each one of them individually, or with any configurations from them
• 4-1a5c When you have your Second Brain, you can have a conversation with it
• Two-way debate makes you realize the relation within your value structures
  • 2-1a Information is in the difference. No difference, no information. 情報とは差異. 区別のないところに情報は生まれない.
    • 3-1c2d Human knowledge is hierarchically structured. It’s a list but also about how things on the list relate to one another. The sum of what we know is greater than all things put together.
      • 3-1c2e 情報は関係性の中にある - Meaning is often in relation to other things
        • Remember: look for surprises, and that configuration is arbitrarycategories
          • 4-1a4b1 You are a configuration of ideas (both conscious and unconscious)
• 対話の方が思考のプロセスがあきらかになっていく
  • 論理をまとめるのはおもしろくない
    • Two-way debate benefits from criticism, but more importantly it increases chance encounters with opportunities for abductions
      • 1-1c5 Surprises are the doors to revealing the inexplicit and the unconscious
      • 2-1a6c5 ‘Randomness’ is the opportunity to reason abductively
    • 1-1a5a A real essay doesn’t take a position and then defend it (deductive). It starts with a question (abductive), in trying to figure something out.
      • 1-1a5a1 The process of argument starts in the middle, and doesn’t start with axioms and end with the conclusion

Counter-examples:

• 趙高と胡亥: 馬鹿の語源 (no-man の排除)
  • Counter-counter-example: 劉邦と張良